Tag Archives: Valhalla Accident

As anniversary of train tragedy nears, MTA focuses on grade crossings

Early in 2016, roughly a year after a Metro-North train struck a Mercedes SUV and derailed, killing the driver and five passengers, the MTA plans to assess the hundreds of crossings where rail meets road.

“Whenever you have an incident of that nature, that visibility and that impact on lives, the loss of life, you do an awful lot of inner-looking,” said MTA chairman Tom Prendergast, at the authority’s monthly board meeting. “And so, grade crossings are a high priority for us.”

There are 437 places in the New York metropolitan area where cars cross Metro-North and Long Island Rail Road tracks. The MTA, via a contractor, already is analyzing 25 of them.

“The initial sampling showed that surveying them closely was helpful, so we’ll do all of them,”

It was on Feb. 3, at one such crossing in Valhalla in Westchester County, that a commuter train crashed into a car on the tracks. In addition to the six deaths, more than dozen people were injured, some gravely.

The National Transportation Safety Board took over the investigation.

On Wednesday, the board released more than 1,100 documents related to the ongoing investigation. The board’s final analysis of the accident hasn’t been released yet.

But the docket contained details about the horror on the train in those minutes after it struck the car.

One unnamed passenger in the front car was playing solitaire on his or her phone when the rumbling began, and the third rail penetrated the right side of the car, hitting another rider on the forehead and killing him instantly.

Sparks flew as the third rail tore through the train.

As the solitaire player made for the exit, he or she saw a body cut in half in the aisle.

“A man adjacent to that rail jumped up and his clothing immediately burst into flames,” William Marshall, a passenger, told the investigators via email.

He threw his coat to the floor and tried stamp out the flames.

Passengers trying to escape to the second car discovered the door was jammed. Others tried to push open the windows but struggled to do so.

Eventually two riders managed to open the right side window. They escaped the train and helped others climb out.

As they stood in the snow outside of the carriage, passengers described the SUV engulfed in flames. Fearing an explosion as the train began to catch fire, some of the approximately 20 passengers in the first car began to wander towards the neighboring cemetery.

A group of riders carried a man who’d lost his left leg below the knee.

The Valhalla accident was the deadliest in Metro-North’s history, and one of a series of deadly incidents, including a derailment in Spuyten Duyvil, that has come to mar the once-sterling reputation of the MTA railroad.

The MTA has since intensified its focus on safety.


Commuter train slams into SUV on tracks, killing 6 people

A crowded commuter train slammed into a sport utility vehicle on the tracks at a suburban New York crossing and burst into flames, killing seven people,

A crowded commuter train slammed into a sport utility vehicle on the tracks at a suburban New York crossing and burst into flames, killing six people, seriously injuring more than a dozen others and sending hundreds of passengers scrambling for safety, authorities said. The collision involved a Metro-North Railroad train and a Jeep Cherokee on Tuesday evening in Valhalla, about 20 miles north of New York City. Authorities said the impact was so forceful the electrified third rail came up and pierced the train.

Killed were the SUV’s driver and five people aboard the train, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said. He said the number train passengers killed in the accident dropped from six to five during an appearance Wednesday on “CBS This Morning.” He did not give a reason for the change in the number of passengers killed.

Cuomo also says that 15 people were injured, seven of them seriously.

Westchester County Executive Rob Astorino said the front part of the train was “completely charred and burned.”

“I am amazed anyone got off that train alive. … It must have been pure panic, with the flames, the third rail and the smoke,” he said.

Authorities said the SUV’s driver had gotten out of her vehicle momentarily after the crossing’s safety gates came down around her. She then got back in and was trying to drive forward when she was hit, they said.

The northbound Metro-North Railroad train left Grand Central Terminal in Manhattan around 5:45 p.m. and struck the SUV about 45 minutes later.

It was unclear how fast the train was going, but the maximum would be 60 mph, a railroad official said.

The train shoved the SUV about 10 train car lengths. Smoke poured out of the scorched front rail car, its windows blackened.

“This is a truly ugly and brutal site,” said Cuomo, who called the crash the railroad’s most deadly.

Witnesses said they saw the flames shooting from where the crash occurred, in a wooded area near a cemetery.

Ryan Cottrell, assistant director at a nearby rock climbing gym, said he had been looking out a window because of an earlier, unrelated car accident and saw the train hit the car, pushing it along.

“The flames erupted pretty quickly,” he said.

Passengers described a bump and said they smelled gasoline from the vehicle.

Around 650 passengers likely were aboard the train, including Justin Kaback, commuting home to Danbury, Connecticut.

“I was trapped. You know there was people in front of me and behind me, and I was trapped in the middle of a car and it was getting very hot,” he told ABC News. “All the air was turned off so there was no circulation so it was definitely scary especially when people are walking by on the outside and they said, ‘The train’s on fire. There’s a fire.'”

– See more at: http://www.uticaod.com/article/20150204/NEWS/150209802#sthash.gARiXkz3.dpuf

Passenger Stacey Eisner, who was at the rear of the train, told NBC News that she felt the train “jerk” and then a conductor walked through the train explaining what had happened. She said her train car was evacuated about 10 minutes later using ladders to get people out.

The other rail passengers were moved to the rear of the train so they could get off. Buses picked them up and took them to other stations.

All railroad grade crossings have gate arms that are designed to lift automatically if they strike something like a car on the way down, railroad safety consultant Grady Cothen said. The arms are made of wood and are designed to be easily broken if a car trapped between them moves forward or backward, he said.

Officials didn’t comment on whether the gates were working properly.

Rick Hope said he was stopped directly behind the SUV and said he started to back up to give her room, but instead she pulled forward.

Hope told WNYW-TV the crossing signals were working properly, and the gate was down and bells were ringing. He said the gate lowered and struck the SUV, and the woman got out looking a bit confused.

He said the woman “kind of” wiggled the gate. He said the SUV was at the track line when she pulled forward.

The National Transportation Safety Board said a team was being sent to investigate.

Metro-North is the nation’s second-busiest commuter railroad, after the Long Island Rail Road. It was formed in 1983 and serves about 280,000 riders a day in New York and Connecticut. Service on its Harlem Line was suspended between Pleasantville and North White Plains after the crash.

Metro-North has been criticized severely for accidents over the last couple of years. Late last year, the NTSB issued rulings on five accidents that occurred in New York and Connecticut in 2013 and 2014, repeatedly finding fault with the railroad while also noting that conditions have improved.

Among the accidents was a Dec. 1, 2013, derailment that killed four people, the railroad’s first passenger fatalities, in the Bronx. The NTSB said the engineer had fallen asleep at the controls because he had a severe, undiagnosed case of sleep apnea.

Last March, the Federal Railroad Administration issued a stinging report on Metro-North, saying it let safety concerns slip while pushing to keep trains on time. Railroad executives pledged to make safety their top priority.

– See more at: http://www.uticaod.com/article/20150204/NEWS/150209802/?Start=2#sthash.gARiXkz3.dpuf